@fluxwavez: If I recall correctly, sometimes running games in compatibility mode has weird effects. Your season 1 saves are probably in some hidden folder created for compatibility mode. I bet that once you find them and move them over to the correct spots (that is, where Season 2 expects them to be), you will be fine. The same thing happened to my Baldur's Gate saves, the saves made during compatibility mode were stored away somewhere else, and thus running the game normally would not allow me to load them.