Andrew initially comes off as a warm, friendly, jovial, and good-willed man. He was willing to invite Lee and the Motel Survivors to his family's dairy, alongside his brother, offering a friendly exchange of food in exchange for gas. He acted sociable in a way that wasn't overly invasive, getting to know more about Lee while engaging in friendly banter. Andrew also seemed kind towards Clementine and Duck, fixing their dairy's swing for them to play on should Lee not do it himself.